The town that slays together, stays together. It's the story of a bully who went too far and the town who decided to do something about it. We have some solidarity here and it's a secret they have kept for over 40 years! Join us as Shawna tells us about the McElroy murder and the Missouri town that knows all and tells nothing. It's a good one! 

We are lightening it up a bit this time, with some mini episodes of the world's dumbest criminals. Join us as Kelley tells us about particularly charismatic lady who loves to keep the home fires burning. Let's just say there are more than skeletons in her attic! This week's challenge is to see who can tell the dumbest story! Kelley may win this one...

A somber tale of a doomed family and no one knows who the culprit is. Is it a prominent State Senator? Or a train-hopping vagrant? Is it connected to other murders along the railroad? Who knows! But Kelley is going to tell us all about it in today's episode. Join us, and tell us who you think won. The Villisca Murders, or the Italian Soap Maker?? 

It is the age old debate - nature versus nurture. Are serial killers made or born? Join us for part one as Shawna takes us to Italy to tell us about the chilling story of the Soap Maker of Correggio. It's going to be "sweet"! 

What do you do when the only place to stay on a lonely road in the middle of nowhere is super sketch? You drive on friend. Unfortunately, too many people didn't follow that little rule and suffered the ultimate consequence. It’s the first family of serial killers documented in the US and Shawna is going to win this round by telling you alllll about it. Come and hang while we talk about the Bloody Benders! 

Join us as we cover the famous Burke and Hare Murders! Also commonly known as the anatomy murders, we are transported back to the early 1800’s in Edinburgh, Scotland where grave robbing is running rampant and anatomy research in the medical community is booming. In comes Burke and Hare who single handedly revolutionize the art of murder for profit. It’s a doozy and we’re excited to share it with you!