I’ll be honest, I listened to episode one just now, not knowing whose show this is! Dang you, Key! You got me. Proof that your work is excellent… I loved this not even knowing it was you!

This quickly became part of my Halloween traditions, but now it’s gone!

I loooove this show so much and I wish there were more seasons and episodes ❤️

There’s no other show out there like this. I can’t believe it ended. I’m very sad. It was awesome! BRING IT BACK PLEASE

So good! It was my pre-Halloween ritual and now I’m left hanging these past two years 😫 Please start these back up, I beg you! 🙏

Love them all & have listened to them many times over. Check every year for new seasons 😎

I’ve been listening since season one. Please bring this back!

Please put out another season!

I loved the first two seasons, the production is great and I adored the concept. It’s a great series to get into the Halloween spirit each year! Its a fun listen and definitely worth the time. Unfortunately I feel like the end of season three fell a bit flat compared to the others. The ending was weak and did not give much closure or explanation. After the twist at the end of season two, I was expecting a lot of this one, but was disappointed. The other seasons also made the anthology approach make sense, and season three took like a pseudo anthology approach. I feel like it didn’t click very well, and that it made the overall story a bit clunky. The other seasons seemed to flow more naturally. I’ve seen some comments about profanity as well, and it is a bit of a let down, but really not a dealbreaker. It’s a horror series, some of that is to be expected. I love this series and highly recommend it, I just feel like season three overall was a bit of a let down compared to the others. UPDATE: complaints aside, I did love this series, I really hope they bring it back!!! Fall isn’t as fun without this!

Hope they put out another season this October.

These grim and mild fiction stories are amazing, bring them back please.

I miss this podcast so much and re-listening to the old seasons does not scratch my itch for more.

Good stories!

I love the quirky human side of horror which has been portrayed so well in this series. I can’t tell you how much I looked forward to this show the past four years. I am quite sad to see it end.

This podcast is one of my favorite Halloween Traditions the past three years, I’m very sad it there wasn’t a story this year. I’ll look forward to it again next year!!! Don’t skip 12 Ghosts this year at Christmas.

I look forward to 13 days of Halloween every October, I’m sad there’s no season 5 this year!

I love these series, I was sad to see we didn’t get one this year =[

One of the Halloween podcasts I look most forward to has no new season! 🥺 I’m crushed!

I love this podcast and was looking forward to hearing it this year. I’m sad we didn’t get one:( Please bring a season 5 next year!!

This is a great binge-able show. Bummed there wasn’t a season 5 this year.

What kinda Halloween prank is this? I look forward to this show every year. Where is season 5?

No new season this year, I looked forward to my nightly wars with this stereo podcast stories. Please Please Please bring this back. I’m re listening to past season 1 and will have to do this as a yearly Halloween tradition until you bring it back

The production/ sound editing is really letting me down on the first episode. Once a specific character enters the narrative, the scratching sounds became a chalkboard in my brain. If you have even mild misophonia, AVOID.

I got so excited to listen to this again this year and am crushed there’s no season 5! It’s such a great show and fun way to get into the spirit of Halloween! Bring it back!!

I look forward to this every year. Hoping to have a season 5 please.

It’s sad to see people that say they loved it and give one star because there’s not a new season.

Are we getting a new season 5 this year.

I love this show. I recently just started listening to Podcasts last year. This is by far my favorite. I love the stories, actors, and production. I wish this was made all year round.

This show is great, and I have been eagerly waiting for season 5, but looks like it’s not going to happen?

I was so looking forward to a new season this year… I guess I will just replay the old seasons. Thank you for what you have given us though 😊

I love this podcast and every year I look forward to a new season. Please, please say there’s going to be a season five this year.🎃

So disappointed there’s no new season this year and wish they would of said that on one of their other podcasts!

I’ve been waiting. 😱

It’s very unfortunate that we don’t get to a Season 5. This was a show that I loved and it really helped get me in the mood for Halloween. Money and rating be damned Grim and Mild. You built a following because of the great concepts and stories for us, and now it feels like capitalism has won out yet again.

Look forward to this every year.

I have been looking forward to the new season but alas it’s not here! Please tell me it’s not gone for good!

Always a good storyline…great actors! Wish there was more podcast like this. Pleeeeeeeassseeeee be another season!!! I am patiently waiting!! This is my favorite podcast. I look forward to this every year…

I look forward to this every year. These are so fun, my favorite way to listen is while walking my dog in the woods. Extra creepy.

I love the 13 Days of Halloween series and 12 Ghosts. I return to these series through out the year. I have probably listed to ear 3 or more times. I am engrossed by the tales and the storytelling. I think this is such a lovely body of work and I look forward to it every year.

Really hope there’s a season 5

Will there be a season? I look forward to this every year!

Will there be one this year?

Is there any way to get away from the anthology model? Every season has a through line, but it’s essentially an anthology series. It’s well written for sure, but I’d like to see a whole cohesive season that doesn’t rely on the anthology method of storytelling.

I haven’t listened to season 3 yet. I just finished season 2. I remember season 1 quite fondly. The creators of this are so totally talented. Leaves you wishing for more.

The latest season was excellent! The writing’s specificity gave it a high degree of realism, and the mystery was well crafted throughout. Space exploration gone wrong would be a fun premise for a future season.

I loved Season 1, it was a great concept that really drew you in with creepy stories. Season 2 wasn’t as good but was definitely worth the listen. I think having the “you” character talk took you out of the story a bit. Season 3 again was not as good as 1 or 2. It really seemed to lose something and was no longer creepy or scary, more so just a mystery story. Season 4 so far has been horrible. I really can’t get into it. Nothing is creepy or scary and the episodes are way way too long. 2 episodes have already been almost an hour…an hour of boring stories does nothing to keep your attention. I’m honestly contemplating not finishing the season and may not even give season 5 a chance (if there is one)… **UPDATE** I finished season 4 and it was just as bad as expected. It started to get slightly better but really fell off again at the end. My rating and review stay the same but I wanted to let readers know that I still think you should skip this season. Save yourself the time and just pass on it. Clearly, I’m not the only one who thinks this as the rating overall has dropped since this season was released. Hopefully Aaron sees this and goes back to the roots of the show for next year.

Didn’t choose this year because prison in real life should scare everyone but it’s a neat way to tell a story. Loved the hotel and seaside ones.

The apple was too much. Lost a star there. Ok the chewing gum in episode eleven was also disgusting. Not sure the point of her microphone being INSIDE her mouth..

The ending ruined the entire thing. It just was so bad I can’t give this more than one star. The storyline was great until the end too. This was incredible until the last two episodes and they completely destroyed the ground work that had been so carefully placed for a phenomenal story. You truly murdered a fantastic series and story with those two pathetic final episodes.

Let me first start with saying how much I love just about every production of Grim and Mild that is made, from Noble Blood to Cabinet of Curiosity and even 13th days of Halloween, which I’ve enjoyed up until season four. this was not scary or entertaining. It was boring and I’m so disappointed. I will listen next season but please bring us the quality production. We know you for from Grimm and Mild.