So hard to listen to!!!!! Worst podcast I’ve ever heard!!! Don’t waste time on these two. The entire episode is a recap of a television show full of inconsistencies to the case. An hour of my life I will never get back! Unbelievable.

Would you had believed Susan Smith bc she was a mother? Ugh

Started out my first listen with the 2 part episodes of Bad Vegan. The main host reading in these episodes seems to keep losing her place in where she’s reading , or her train of thought . She also keeps referring to the main criminal by two different names . Yes he had an alias , but her using two names back and forth within one missive , is Very confusing . Also, the second host keeps talking over her, and a few times I had rewind a bit to try and make out what was said . Doubt I’ll stay subscribed , but now I’m sucked into the story and want to hear the end . Another note, if the main reader in these 2 episodes would drop the secondary one , I’d be more apt to stick around . Secondary host has a Very shrill voice .

Yes for the research but no for the amount of cursing and too much “ok.. yeah… ok, yah..”

I want to like them… but the poor articulation, abundance of valley speak ‘like’ and ‘Umm yeahh’, poorly placed awkward pauses and script reading kill it for me. It’s like sitting at the wrong lunch table in high school.

These women are foul-fouled idiots. Don’t waste your time.

Every other word is “like”. Like, how annoying.

Y’all are my Besties in my head! Love your podcast! Keep them coming!

I’ve listened to 1 podcast so far and I’m so excited to listen to more. This podcast will become one of my regulars.

Love this podcast! Easy to listen to and researched. Keep up the great work!!

A bit hard to get through because the chemistry between the two narrators seemed distant and awkward. And there were a lot of awkward pauses.

I just discovered this podcast and I love it!

Binged all episodes within 24 hours. Enjoyable podcast and despite the dark content the episodes still manage to end on positive notes, definitely recommend.

Tons of true crime stories I haven’t heard about with great research. Very intense stuff delivered in a respectable but fun way

I’m intrigued. I’ll watch the show. Unbelievable!

This is such a comical, raw, and easy to listen to podcast. Will be subscribed forever! The recent Jeff’s episode is just crazy and entertaining even though I’ve heard this story many times before. The chemistry that these two friends have is contagious and makes me want to drink wine with them! Keep it up ladies. Cheers!

Every episode is like they’re reading Wiki pages and they have zero self awareness. Stop interrupting each other talking like you’re 80’s valley girls. Completely surprised the “gag me with a spoon” wasn’t uttered at least once. So many better true crime podcasts out there.

So many true crime podcasts spend the first 20-40 minutes talking about things unrelated to the podcast. This one doesn’t do that (YAY!). They get straight to the point, the episodes keep me intrigued throughout, and Chelsea really does her homework. Really enjoying this podcast. Keep em coming Chelsea and Jo!