This week, the guys talk about the StarKid musical horror-comedy The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals. When a meteor hits the town of Hatchetfield, it brings with it an alien force that wants to make everyone sing and dance.

Also in this episode: Billy goes through a Choose Your Own Adventure, Brad reveals his prejudices and calls out one of the Star Kid cast members, and would you cry if Sir Paul McCartney was killed in front of you?